Home » What Is Your Editing Process? (An #AuthorToolBoxBlogHop Post)

What is Your Editing Process?

What Is Your Editing Process? (An #AuthorToolBoxBlogHop Post)

This post is part of the monthly Author Toolbox Blog Hop, organised by Raimey Gallant, with over 40 blogs participating. To find more posts, click here to check out the main page, search #AuthorToolBoxBlogHop on Twitter, or click here to find us on Pinterest.

I’ve recently read Write Like a Boss! by Honoree Corder and Ben Hale. It’s an excellent short book, and I recommend it. If you write fiction, it’s worth the purchase price simply for Chapter Four, where Ben Hale details his personal revision and editing process.

Ben says:

My draft process is thirteen drafts. But it didn’t start our that way. My first book went through twenty-four drafts, and still has errors.

Wow. Just wow.

I have two initial comments about Ben’s editing process:

  1. His process is actually fourteen steps: he doesn’t count his initial detailed outline as a draft. Ben is obviously a plotter, not a pantser. I suspect a pantser would need more drafts.
  2. Ben is an experienced fiction writer. A less experienced writer, who doesn’t know some of the “rules” of fiction, will need more drafts. For example, if you write in third person but don’t know what headhopping is, you’ll probably need one full pass through your manuscript to identify headhopping, and one full draft to fix your point of view. Maybe two.

As a freelance editor, I found it interesting to see where Ben’s copyeditor fit in the process. His copyeditor sees the fifth draft of the book—he goes though the full book another eight times before he publishes, which shows there is more to editing than many authors realize.

So here is an outline of Ben’s editing process with my comments (if you want Ben’s comments, buy the book!).

Draft 0: Outline

Ben write in series, so his outline includes a series outline, outlines for the individual books, and even the chapters. Outlining means he will already know the genre, plot, story arc, characters, theme and the aims for each scene before he starts writing. If you don’t outline, this may mean four to six additional drafts to make sure you’ve nailed these essentials.

A critique partner may help brainstorm some of these plot and character issues at the outline stage.

Draft 1: Finish

The aim here is to get a completed manuscript to edit. If you’re doing NaNoWriMo next month, this is probably what you’re aiming for.

Draft 2: Content

Fill in holes and add detail. I suspect this is where a lot of authors think their work ends. Now they send it to an editor and that’s it, right? Nope.

Draft 3: Alpha Reader

Ben’s alpha readers ignore grammar and typos and focus on the big picture issues: what’s working in terms of the big issues of plot, character, story, and theme, what isn’t working, and what’s missing.

Some authors may work with a critique partner who fills this role. Others may hire an editor to undertake a developmental edit or manuscript assessment.

Draft 4: Character Building

Use comments from the alpha reader to fill out the characters and make them real.

A pantser may need to add another draft in here around plot: filling in the plot holes, and deleting extraneous scenes. After all, you don’t want to pay an editor to edit 3,000 words that don’t drive the plot forward.

Draft 5: Editor

Always submit the best possible draft to your editor. It will help keep the cost down if you’ve already removed the hundreds of adverbs, that’s, very’s, and other overused words, and fixed all the typos you can find. It also means your editor can focus on the things you can’t fix.

Draft 6: Post Editor Partial

Accept or reject minor changes (e.g. spelling and grammar), and undertake sentence-level improvements e.g. adding rhetorical devices, adding fresh descriptions and body language (no “he nodded” or “she shrugged”). If you have no idea what I mean, head on over to Lawson Writer’s Academy and sign up for Deep Editing, Rhetorical Devices, and More.

Draft 7: Post Editor Full

Now the story is free from Track Changes, address any major story issues (like that scene you should have cut and didn’t).

Draft 8: Word Draft

Polishing: checking character names are spelled correctly and consistently, and haven’t been used in other books. Run spell check. Fix the typos and mistakes you introduced in Drafts 6 and 7. Review your editorial letter and make sure you haven’t added back any of the adverbs the editor “suggested” you cut. (Because it wasn’t a suggestion. It was an order.)

You might ask why the editor didn’t catch some of these things. They may have, but they might miss tiny things while they fix big things. Your editor might not know that you called the character Jaime in the last book, but this book calls him Jayme.

It’s also a numbers game. It’s not unusual for me to suggest 10,000 changes in a 100,000 word novel. Even if I’m 99.9% accurate, I’ll still miss 100 changes. And the author might add a few hundred more as they revise and edit. This is why trade published novels go through at least three rounds of editing … and still aren’t perfect.

Draft 9: Beta Readers

Ben suggests at least five beta readers, and they have to be honest. You need your beta readers to find what’s wrong, not gush over how clever you are that you’ve written a whole book all by yourself. Please. You’re not five. Adult up and seek honest critical feedback. (But you don’t have to accept mean feedback. People can be critical without being mean).

How to pick beta readers is probably a whole separate blog post. Like this one from #AuthorToolBoxBlogHop participant JR Creaden: 5 Things To Do Before You Beta Your Book.

Draft 10: Post Beta Reader

Add changes suggested by beta readers.

Draft 11: Vocal Drafts

Reading out loud is a great way of catching sentences that don’t quite make sense, or don’t sound right (especially in dialogue). I’ll often read awkward sentences out loud when I’m editing for other people as a way of finding and fixing a problem.

Draft 12: Final Beta Reader

One final read-through to catch last-minute typos. I think it’s best if this person hasn’t read the full story before (although they may have add early input at Draft 0 or 1). The reason for this suggestion is that we often see the words we think are on the page, not the words which are actually there. For this draft, you want someone who is going to read the words on the page, not fill in the blanks because they’ve already read the story almost as many times as you have.

Draft 13: Final and Format

Fix final typos, format, and add front and back matter (make sure you double check the spelling of any people you thank. It kind of takes away from the buzz of being mentioned if the author spells your name wrong. True story).

This draft process is not for everyone. In fact, it probably only works for me. But hopefully it helps you get a start on your own if you don’t already have one.

This process (or something like it) will be useful for me as a writer. It’s also going to be useful for me as a freelance editor, as it shows clients where Editor-Me falls in the writing and revision process.

As I said, I do recommend Write Like a Boss! It has heaps of great tips for both fiction and non-fiction writers.

Do you have an editing process? What does it look like?

This is the final #AuthorToolBoxBlogHop post for 2017. We figure everyone will be busy with NaNoWriMo in November, and Christmas in December. We’ll be back in January 2018. Meanwhile, I’ll still post every Wednesday (writing or marketing) and Saturday (Best of the Blogs). Well, except for Christmas and New Year.

Meanwhile, check out more #AuthorToolBoxBlogHop posts:

Click here to check out the main page.

#AuthorToolBoxBlogHop is on Twitter.

Click here to find us on Pinterest.

Subscribe to my monthly newsletter and receive an exclusive guide to publishers specializing in Christian fiction.

You're subscribed! Check your email for your exclusive guide to publishers specializing in Christian fiction. If you don't get it within ten minutes, email me at igoulton@christianediting.co.nz.

21 comments

  1. Wow! This looks exactly like my writing/editing process… and I’ve never even read the book 😉 When I started writing I thought I was done around draft 5 or 6 — those stories will stay safely hidden on a dusty hard drive. Through trial and error I’ve arrived at this editing process. It’s proven quite effective: my short stories are appearing in anthologies. Now to make sure the novels are just as great.

    Thanks for sharing. It’s heartening to know that my trial-and-error process is actually used by others.

  2. Erika Beebe says:

    Iola, this post is so insightful and timely for me. Thank you. I love how each of the editing drafts is very specific to one purpose. I had never thought of this and will definitely pick up the book. Thank you 🙂

  3. Caroliena C says:

    Great post, and wow! That’s a lot of drafts. I do think drafts and editing are so important, but I’m still trying to figure out what’s ideal for me. Thanks for sharing!

    • Iola says:

      Yes, I’m still trying to work out what’s ideal for me as well. In some ways, it feels much easier to work on someone else’s manuscript than my own. I figure the more I understand about how other people edit, the better job I can do of coming up with a process that works for me, but doesn’t miss anything important.

  4. Charity Rau says:

    This is so helpful! I will have to check out the book. I’m in the middle of editing a manuscript and it seems like I still keep finding things to fix. Glad to know others do so many drafts as well. Thanks for sharing!

    • Iola says:

      I’m about to get into heavy editing (if I don’t procrastinate by signing up for Nano). I suspect I’m going to have to be disciplined and know what I’m looking for on each editing pass, and fixing only that.

  5. I find it odd that beta readers come after editors here. To get the best possible draft before an editor, I send it to betas and critique partners (alphas). I wouldn’t want to pay an editor if I haven’t exhausted every avenue of progression first. Then again, I’d still want readers to look at it AFTER I made editor’s changes. As an editor myself, I agree wholeheartedly with the statement: “After all, you don’t want to pay an editor to edit 3,000 words that don’t drive the plot forward.” Cut as much as possible, and give your editor the best book you can. That means they’ll help you make one that’s even better than your best!

    http://micascottikole.com/2017/10/17/wdc17-3-mechanics-plot-twists-authortoolbox/

    • Iola says:

      I suspect some authors use multiple beta readers in the way Hale uses his alpha reader. Then you have authors like Dean Wesley Smith who don’t use beta readers at all.

      I do agree: I want to get my manuscript to the highest standard possible before I pay an editor. For me, that means getting input from critique partners and beta readers first. But I can see the logic in Hale’s process, especially given his genre (fantasy), and the fact he’s a plotter not a pantser.

  6. JJ Burry says:

    I’m in the revision process myself. I’m not entirely sure how many drafts I’ll have, but I’m about to start the third draft.

    Great post! I’ve heard of this book, and I’ll definitely check it out. I like the steps you give here from it!

  7. Lupa says:

    Wow! I, obviously, have not been doing enough editing. Or at least, my editing process is nothing as constructive as this. The greatest detriment to the completion of my drafting process is that I edit so much as I write that first draft. I simply cannot restrain myself from returning to the beginning and make changes as I read back a chapter to where I left off every time I sit down to draft a new scene – slowing me down terribly. I am working to rectify my habit. But what you have outlined here is simply puts me in my place, heh heh *laughs nervously* I have my work cut out for me but at least now I know what it is.

    • Iola says:

      Perhaps you need to try plotting, so you can train yourself to write forwards?

      I think we all develop our own editing processes over time, and they will depend on what we are writing. Blog posts don’t need this much editing. Even non-fiction books can be easier to edit. Novels are hard, because it’s not just about getting the right words on paper (or PC) in order. It’s about genre and theme and plot and structure and scene structure and characterisation, then going back to make sure you’ve woven all the ingredients into the right place … it seems neverending.

    • Iola says:

      Ben Hale said he originally had 24 drafts, and now he’s down to 13. Looking at my own fiction writing and the manuscripts I assess and edit, I can see where those extra stages can come in, and how they can be dropped as we learn the craft.

  8. Thanks for sharing these tips on editing. I do most of them, but do see some to include now. Finding beta readers is always the toughest part for me. I want readers whose work I admire. All the best to you!

  9. I find the line between drafts is blurred. By the time I get the ending written, I’ve already gone back and tweaked the beginning, routing out sneaky typos and deepening the character’s motivation, polishing the first chapters to a high shine while the latter chapters still have “Something Happens Here” placeholders.
    My problem is that I never know when to say “when.” I could polish endlessly. I have to send the ms. to a beta reader just to find out how much work I still need to do.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *